How the Monthly Pie Box Works
A box of pies every month, collected from your local spot. Here is the whole thing, including the maths and the bit where your twelfth box is twice the size.
Chris Thomas ·
The subscription is the thing I get asked about most and explain worst, usually over a counter with a queue behind you. So here it is written down properly, including the parts that are less flattering.
The simple version
You pick your pies. You pick where you collect them. Once a month they are there waiting for you, and you do not have to think about it again.
That is the whole product. Everything below is detail.
What it costs, and the honest maths
Your first box is full price. That is deliberate, and I will come back to it.
From your second box onward you pay 10% less, and you keep paying 10% less for as long as you stay subscribed. It is not an introductory rate that quietly expires.
Your price is locked for a full year from the day you sign up. If our prices go up in March, yours does not. You stay on what you agreed to.
And then there is the one nobody expects. Your twelfth box is twice the size, for the same money. Same charge, double the pies. It is our way of saying thanks for sticking around for a year, and it works out as roughly thirteen boxes for the price of twelve.
Why is the first box full price when most places discount it? Because I would rather earn the discount than use it as bait. Plenty of subscriptions are cheap to join and annoying to leave. This one gets better the longer you stay, which is the right way round.
The minimum
Four pies a month. That is two of our two-packs, in any combination you like.
It is not a sales tactic, it is a practical floor. Below that the admin and the packing cost more than the order is worth, and I would rather have a sensible minimum than quietly put the prices up to cover it.
You can change the box every month
This is the part people do not realise, and it is the best thing about it.
Your box is not fixed. Every month, right up to the cutoff, you can go into your account and change:
- Which pies are in it. Steak and Ale this month, Shepherd’s next, Chili Sin Carne the month after.
- How many. Four pies in a quiet month, twelve when you have people coming.
- Where you collect it. Switched jobs, moved across town, prefer the brewery to the shop. Change it yourself.
After the cutoff, it locks. You will get a message saying the month has already gone to the kitchen, because by then it genuinely has. Whatever you change after that applies to your next box instead.
Pausing and cancelling
You can pause or cancel yourself, from your account, whenever you like. No email to me, no form, no three working days, no being talked out of it.
Going away for a month? Pause it. Had enough? Cancel it. If you pause or cancel before a cutoff, you are not charged for that cycle at all.
I have been on the other end of a subscription you have to ring someone to escape. Never again.
Nothing is charged when you sign up
We save your card and charge it a few days before each collection, after the cutoff has passed and we know what you actually want in the box.
So signing up today does not cost you anything today.
The one thing it does not do
The subscription is collected, not posted.
You choose a collection point when you sign up, somewhere in Kansas City, and that is where your box is each month. We do not currently post subscription boxes.
If you are out of state, that is not the end of it. We do ship one-off orders anywhere in the lower 48, flat $29.99 however much you order, and you can read about how the shipping works. It is just a separate thing from the monthly box.
Would I like to post subscriptions nationwide one day? Yes. It is not built yet and I am not going to pretend otherwise.
The dates that matter right now
The next box is collected on Thursday 31 December, and changes close on Monday 28 December.
So if you sign up today, your first box is a New Year’s Eve one. Which is good timing if you have people round, and less good if you were hoping to be fed before Christmas.
If you want pies for Christmas itself, don’t wait for the subscription. Put a normal order in instead. You can order right up to the last collection before Christmas and have them in the freezer, then start the monthly box in the new year when things have calmed down.
Is it actually worth it?
If you buy pies two or three times a year, no. Buy them when you want them and enjoy them.
If there is more or less always a Brit Boy pie in your freezer, then yes, obviously. You are paying 10% less for something you were buying anyway, your price is frozen for a year, and at some point a box turns up twice the size.
I wrote a separate piece on ordering online versus buying at the market that goes through the numbers. The short version is that the more you buy at once, the more the online prices make sense, and the subscription is the furthest end of that.